Acrylic vs. Oil Paints: Understanding the Key Differences

September 2, 2024

Acrylic paints are known for their quick-drying properties, bright colours, and versatility, making them ideal for artists who want to layer quickly or create bold, graphic effects. They dry to a durable, water-resistant finish and can be easily mixed with various mediums to alter their texture and sheen. On the other hand, oil paints offer a slower drying time, allowing for more extended blending and layering, which is perfect for achieving rich, subtle gradations of colour. Oil paints provide a natural, luminous finish and are favoured for their depth and richness in colour, making them ideal for traditional and classical painting techniques.

Choosing the right paint can significantly impact the outcome of your artwork. Two of the most popular types of paint among artists are acrylic and oil paints. Each has its unique characteristics, strengths, and potential drawbacks. In this guide, we’ll explore the key differences between acrylic and oil paints to help you decide which medium suits your creative needs best.

Acrylic Paints: Quick-Drying and Versatile

Acrylic paints are beloved for their versatility and quick-drying properties. This type of paint is made from pigment suspended in an acrylic polymer emulsion, which is water-soluble when wet but becomes water-resistant once dry.

Key Characteristics of Acrylic Paints:

Quick Drying: Acrylics dry rapidly, sometimes within minutes, depending on the thickness of the paint. This allows artists to layer and rework their paintings in a short amount of time, making it ideal for artists who work quickly or who enjoy building up texture.
Bright, Bold Colours: Acrylic paints are known for their vibrant colours, which retain their brightness even after drying. This makes them perfect for creating graphic, modern styles of art.
Versatility: Acrylics can be used on a variety of surfaces, including canvas, wood, paper, and even fabric. They can also be mixed with mediums to create different textures and finishes, from matte to glossy.
Easy Clean-Up: Since acrylic paints are water-based, brushes and palettes can be cleaned easily with just water before the paint dries.

When to Choose Acrylic Paints:

Acrylic paints are an excellent choice for beginners and professionals alike, especially if you’re looking for a medium that dries quickly and offers a broad range of creative possibilities. They’re particularly well-suited for artists who like to experiment with different techniques, such as mixed media or impasto, or who need a fast-drying option for their projects.

Oil Paints: Richness and Depth of Colour

Oil paints have been the preferred medium for many of the world’s greatest artists, from Rembrandt to Van Gogh. These paints are made by suspending pigment in oil, usually linseed oil, which gives them a rich, buttery consistency.

Key Characteristics of Oil Paints:

Slow Drying: Unlike acrylics, oil paints take much longer to dry, often several days or even weeks, depending on the thickness of the application. This slow drying time allows artists to blend colours seamlessly and work on their paintings over an extended period.
Depth and Richness: Oil paints are renowned for their depth of colour and the ability to create subtle gradations and transitions. The natural oils in the paint give it a luminous quality that is difficult to achieve with other mediums.
Blending and Layering: The extended drying time of oil paints makes them ideal for techniques that require blending and layering, such as the Alla Prima or wet-on-wet technique. This is particularly useful for creating realistic portraits, landscapes, and still life.
Durability: Once fully cured, oil paintings are incredibly durable and have been known to last for centuries. The paint forms a strong, flexible film that is less likely to crack over time.

When to Choose Oil Paints:

Oil paints are best suited for artists who appreciate the process of painting over an extended period, allowing for careful adjustments and blending. They’re ideal for traditional techniques and styles that require depth, detail, and a rich colour palette. If you’re working on a piece that you want to last a lifetime, oil paints are a worthy investment.

Which is Right for You?

The choice between acrylic and oil paints ultimately depends on your personal preferences and the demands of your project.

Choose Acrylics If: You need a fast-drying paint, enjoy working with bright, bold colours, or want a versatile medium that can be used on a variety of surfaces.
Choose Oils If: You prefer a slow-drying paint that allows for extended blending, layering, and detailed work. Oils are also the better choice if you’re looking to create artwork with a rich, natural colour palette that will stand the test of time.

Conclusion

Both acrylic and oil paints offer unique benefits that can enhance your artwork. Whether you’re drawn to the quick-drying versatility of acrylics or the rich, luminous qualities of oils, there’s a perfect paint for every artist and project.

At P9 Art Boutique, we offer a range of high-quality paint products to suit every artistic style. Our P9 Artisan Oil Paint Kit and P9 Artist Oil Paint Set provide everything you need to create stunning works of art, whether you’re a fan of traditional oil painting techniques or prefer the flexibility of acrylics. Explore our collection today and find the perfect tools to bring your creative vision to life.

Back to blog

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Are handmade oil paints suitable for beginners?

Yes, handmade oil paints are suitable for beginner artists, especially those interested in learning more about the paint-making process and controlling the quality of their materials. Making oil paint from scratch can help you better understand pigments, textures, and the chemistry of paint. For beginners, our P9 Artisan Oil Paint Kit is a perfect introduction, providing high-quality, non-toxic pigments and materials for a safe and rewarding experience.

What materials do I need to make my own oil paints?

To make your own oil paints, you'll need the following materials:

Pigments: Dry, finely ground powders in the colours of your choice.
Drying Oil: Linseed oil, walnut oil, or other natural oils to bind the pigments.
Palette Knife: For mixing the pigments with the oil.
Glass Muller and Grinding Plate: These tools help ensure the pigment is evenly dispersed into the oil for a smooth, professional-quality paint.
Paint Tubes: For storing your handmade paints.

Our P9 Artisan Oil Paint Kit comes with nine high-quality natural, Earth and synthetic mineral pigments, along with a natural oil binder, perfect for those looking to make their own non-toxic oil paints.

Please note:The mixing tools are not included in the kit.

How do I store homemade oil paints?

To keep your mixed oil paints fresh and maintain their quality, here are some effective storage methods:

Airtight Aluminium Tubes: Transfer your mixed oil paints into airtight aluminium tubes to minimize air exposure. Fill the tube about three-quarters full, then flatten and fold the end using a putty knife. Pinch the end with pliers to seal it airtight. Properly sealed, your paint can last for weeks or even months.
Refrigeration: Store your palette in the refrigerator to slow down drying. This method can keep your paint usable for several days to a week. Make sure to cover the palette with cling film or place it in an airtight container before refrigerating.
Freezing: For longer storage, place your palette in the freezer. This can keep your paint fresh for several weeks. Before using the paint, let it warm up slightly to avoid condensation. This method is especially handy if you paint regularly.
Cling Film: Cover your palette with cling film to reduce air exposure. This is a quick and easy way to keep your paint usable for a few days.
Glass Jars: For longer storage, transfer your paint into small glass jars. Adding a few drops of clove oil can help prevent the paint from drying out too quickly. Ensure the jars are tightly sealed.
Aluminium Foil: Scrape any leftover paint onto small squares of aluminium foil and fold it to create an airtight seal. This can preserve your paint for a few weeks. Label the foil with a smudge of the paint colour for easy identification.

Using these methods will help you extend the life of your mixed oil paints, ensuring you get the most out of your materials.

When were oil paints invented?

Oil paints are believed to have been invented around the early 15th century, with Jan van Eyck, a Flemish painter, often credited for refining the medium. While oil paints may have existed before this, it was during the Northern Renaissance that their use became widespread. Van Eyck's use of linseed oil as a binder allowed for richer colours, smoother blending, and slower drying times, which changed the art world and led to the eventual dominance of oil paints in Europe.

What did artists use before oil paint was invented?

Before the invention of oil paint, artists primarily used egg tempera and encaustic (a wax-based paint) as their main painting mediums. Egg tempera, made from pigment mixed with egg yolk, was widely used in the Byzantine and Renaissance periods due to its fast drying properties and ability to produce fine detail. Encaustic paints, created with pigments suspended in hot beeswax, were commonly used in ancient Egypt for portraiture. These mediums offered longevity but lacked the flexibility and blendability of oil paints.

Can oil paints be used for Alla Prima painting?

Yes, oil paints are perfect for the Alla Prima or "wet-on-wet" technique. This method allows artists to apply layers of oil paint without waiting for the previous layers to dry, creating a more spontaneous and immediate painting style. Natural oil paints, like those found in our P9 Artisan Oil Paint Kit, are excellent for Alla Prima as they offer vibrant colours and smooth blending without toxic solvents, making them ideal for both beginners and professional artists.

What are non-toxic oil paints?

Non-toxic oil paints are made without harmful chemicals, heavy metals, or volatile organic compounds (VOCs) that are commonly found in traditional oil paints. Instead, they use natural pigments and binders like linseed or walnut oil, offering a safer alternative for artists and the environment. These paints are free from toxic additives like cadmium, lead, and cobalt, which can cause health issues over time. Non-toxic oil paints, such as those found in our P9 Artist Oil Paint Set, are perfect for art lovers, students, and professionals who prioritise safety while maintaining vibrant, high-quality results.

Are natural oil paints better for the environment?

Yes, natural oil paints are far better for the environment compared to synthetic oil paints. Traditional oil paints often contain toxic additives, stabilisers, and heavy metals that pose risks to both the artist and the environment. In contrast, natural oil paints use eco-friendly, non-toxic pigments and natural binders, reducing their environmental impact. Our P9 Artist Oil Paint Set is an excellent option for artists looking for vegan, non-toxic oil paints that are safe and sustainable.

How to fix hardened oil paint?

If your oil paint has hardened or become too thick to use, here are a few methods to fix it and restore its workability:

Add Linseed Oil or Other Paint Mediums: If the oil paint is just starting to dry out or has become thick, adding a few drops of linseed oil or a specialised oil painting medium can help rehydrate the paint and restore its creamy texture. Mix thoroughly using a palette knife until the paint is smooth again.
Use a Paint Thinner: For more stubbornly hardened paint, you can add a small amount of odourless mineral spirits, turpentine, or another non-toxic paint thinner to dissolve the dried portions. Be careful not to add too much, as it can make the paint too thin and affect its consistency.
Warm the Paint Gently: Slightly warming the hardened paint (by placing the tube in warm water or near a mild heat source) can soften it enough to mix more easily with a medium. Be careful not to overheat the paint, as this could damage the pigments.
Use a Palette Knife: If only the surface of the paint has hardened, you can scrape off the dried layer with a palette knife and use the softer paint underneath.

If your oil paint has fully dried and hardened, it may not be salvageable. Oil paints naturally dry through oxidation, and if too much air has been exposed to the paint over time, it may have cured beyond repair. To avoid this, ensure your paint tubes are tightly sealed when not in use.